diff --git a/src/core/chat.rs b/src/core/chat.rs
index a3db701..003c617 100644
--- a/src/core/chat.rs
+++ b/src/core/chat.rs
@@ -41,7 +41,8 @@ pub enum BotMsgType {
     // SayInReplyTo(&'a PrivmsgMessage,String),
     // SayInReplyTo(Arc<Box<dyn ReplyToMessage>>,String),
     // SayInReplyTo(&'a dyn ReplyToMessage,String), // [ ] 04.03 - Having issues defining it this way?
-    SayInReplyTo((String,String),String), // ( Destination Channel , Message ID to reply to ) , OutMessage // https://docs.rs/twitch-irc/latest/twitch_irc/client/struct.TwitchIRCClient.html#method.say_in_reply_to
+    // SayInReplyTo((String,String),String), // ( Destination Channel , Message ID to reply to ) , OutMessage // https://docs.rs/twitch-irc/latest/twitch_irc/client/struct.TwitchIRCClient.html#method.say_in_reply_to
+    SayInReplyTo(Channel,String,String), // ( Destination Channel , Message ID to reply to , OutMessage ) // https://docs.rs/twitch-irc/latest/twitch_irc/client/struct.TwitchIRCClient.html#method.say_in_reply_to
     Say(String,String),
     Notif(String), // For Bot Sent Notifications
 }
@@ -88,10 +89,11 @@ impl Chat {
         */
 
         let (channel_login,mut outmsg) = match msginput.clone() {
-            BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(msg, outmsg) => {
+            // BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(msg, outmsg) => {
+            BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(chnl, _, outmsg) => {
                 // (msg.channel_login.clone(),outmsg)
                 // (msg.clone().channel_login().to_string(),outmsg)
-                (msg.0, // Desintation Channel
+                (chnl.0.to_lowercase(), // Desintation Channel
                     outmsg)
             },
             BotMsgType::Say(a,b ) => {
@@ -123,13 +125,16 @@ impl Chat {
             ).await;
 
         if !params.bot.read().await.bot_channels.contains(&Channel(channel_login.clone())) {
+
+            dbg!("ISSUE : NONJOINED CHANNEL",&params.bot.read().await.bot_channels,Channel(channel_login.clone()));
             botlog::warn(
                 &format!("A message attempted to send for a Non-Joined Channel : {}",channel_login.clone()),
                 Some("Chat > send_botmsg".to_string()),
                 None,
             );
 
-            if let BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_prvmsg,_outmsg) = msginput {
+            // if let BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_prvmsg,_outmsg) = msginput {
+            if let BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_chnl,_msgid, _outmsg) = msginput {
 
                 self.send_botmsg(BotMsgType::Notif(
                     "uuh Bot can't send to a channel it isn't joined".to_string(), 
@@ -177,7 +182,8 @@ impl Chat {
 
             match msginput {
                 BotMsgType::Notif(_) => (), // Do nothing with Notif > We'll validate the user later to handle
-                BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_, _) | BotMsgType::Say(_,_) => {
+                // BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_, _) | BotMsgType::Say(_,_) => {
+                BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_, _, _) | BotMsgType::Say(_,_) => {
                             
                         botlog::trace(
                             "BEFORE potential Async recursion",
@@ -276,7 +282,8 @@ impl Chat {
                             return;
                         }
                     },
-                    BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_,_ ) | BotMsgType::Say(_,_) => {
+                    // BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_,_ ) | BotMsgType::Say(_,_) => {
+                    BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_,_,_ ) | BotMsgType::Say(_,_) => {
                         // If the BotMsg a Say/SayInReplyTo (from Developer or Chatter) , and the Sender does not have Specific Roles in the Source Channel Sent
 
                         self.send_botmsg(BotMsgType::Notif(
@@ -349,18 +356,25 @@ impl Chat {
                 }
 
                 match msginput.clone() {
-                    BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(msg, _) => {
+                    // BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(msg, _) => {
+                    // BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(msg, _, _) => {
+                    BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(chnl,msgid, _) => {
+
+                        // dbg!(msg.clone().channel_login(),msg.message_id(),outmsg.clone());
+                        dbg!(chnl.clone(),msgid.clone(),outmsg.clone());
 
-                        dbg!(msg.clone().channel_login(),msg.message_id(),outmsg.clone());
                         self.client.say_in_reply_to(&(
-                            msg.clone().channel_login().to_string(),
-                            msg.message_id().to_string()), 
+                            chnl.0,
+                            msgid), 
                             outmsg).await.unwrap();
                     },
                     BotMsgType::Say(a, _) => {
                         self.client.say(a, outmsg).await.unwrap();
                     }
                     BotMsgType::Notif(outmsg) => {
+
+                        // dbg!(chnl.clone(),msgid.clone(),outmsg.clone());
+                        dbg!(params.msg.channel_login(),params.msg.message_id());
                         self.client.say_in_reply_to(&params.msg, outmsg).await.unwrap();
                     }
                 }
@@ -372,7 +386,8 @@ impl Chat {
                     channel_login.clone(), "rate limit counter increase", contextratelimiter
                 );
 
-                if let BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_,_ ) = msginput {
+                // if let BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_,_ ) = msginput {
+                if let BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(_,_,_ ) = msginput {
                     botlog::trace(
                         logstr.as_str(),
                         Some("Chat > send_botmsg".to_string()),
@@ -408,7 +423,14 @@ impl Chat {
     // #[async_recursion]
     // pub async fn say_in_reply_to(&self, msg: &PrivmsgMessage, outmsg: String , params : ExecBodyParams) {
     // pub async fn say_in_reply_to(&self, msg: &PrivmsgMessage, outmsg: String , params : ExecBodyParams) {
-        pub async fn say_in_reply_to(&self, msg: &impl ReplyToMessage, outmsg: String , params : ExecBodyParams) {
+    // pub async fn say_in_reply_to(&self, msg: &impl ReplyToMessage, outmsg: String , params : ExecBodyParams) {
+    pub async fn say_in_reply_to(
+        &self, 
+        destination_channel : Channel , 
+        reply_message_id : String ,
+        outmsg: String , 
+        params : ExecBodyParams) 
+    {
 
         // let params_clone = params.clone();
 
@@ -462,9 +484,9 @@ impl Chat {
 
 
         self.send_botmsg(BotMsgType::SayInReplyTo(
-                (msg.channel_login().to_string(),
-                msg.message_id().to_string()), 
-            outmsg) , params).await;
+                destination_channel,
+                reply_message_id, 
+                outmsg) , params).await;
 
     }
 
diff --git a/src/custom/experimental/experiment001.rs b/src/custom/experimental/experiment001.rs
index 65bae8b..e774055 100644
--- a/src/custom/experimental/experiment001.rs
+++ b/src/custom/experimental/experiment001.rs
@@ -15,6 +15,7 @@ const OF_CMD_CHANNEL:Channel = Channel(String::new());
 
 
 use rand::Rng;
+use twitch_irc::message::ReplyToMessage;
 use std::sync::Arc;
 
 use crate::core::bot_actions::ExecBodyParams;
@@ -140,7 +141,8 @@ async fn rp(params : ExecBodyParams)
         .chat
         .say_in_reply_to(
             //using the tuple as param to the message being replied
-            &answear,
+            Channel(answear.0),
+            answear.1,
             String::from("hey there"),
             params.clone()
         ).await; 
@@ -188,7 +190,8 @@ async fn good_girl(params : ExecBodyParams) {
             .botmgrs
             .chat
             .say_in_reply_to(
-                &params.msg, 
+                Channel(params.clone().msg.channel_login().to_string()),
+                params.clone().msg.message_id().to_string(), 
                 String::from("GoodGirl xdd "),
                 params.clone()
             ).await;
@@ -228,7 +231,8 @@ async fn babygirl(params : ExecBodyParams) {
         .botmgrs
         .chat
         .say_in_reply_to(
-            &params.msg, 
+            Channel(params.clone().msg.channel_login().to_string()),
+            params.clone().msg.message_id().to_string(), 
             String::from("16:13 notohh: cafdk"),
             params.clone()
         ).await;
@@ -240,7 +244,8 @@ async fn babygirl(params : ExecBodyParams) {
     .botmgrs
     .chat
     .say_in_reply_to(
-        &params.msg, 
+        Channel(params.clone().msg.channel_login().to_string()),
+        params.clone().msg.message_id().to_string(), 
         String::from("16:13 notohh: have fun eating princess"),
         params.clone()
     ).await;
@@ -252,7 +257,8 @@ async fn babygirl(params : ExecBodyParams) {
     .botmgrs
     .chat
     .say_in_reply_to(
-        &params.msg, 
+        Channel(params.clone().msg.channel_login().to_string()),
+        params.clone().msg.message_id().to_string(), 
         String::from("16:13 notohh: baby girl"),
         params.clone()
     ).await;
diff --git a/src/custom/experimental/experiment002.rs b/src/custom/experimental/experiment002.rs
index a4ecb25..a7d1610 100644
--- a/src/custom/experimental/experiment002.rs
+++ b/src/custom/experimental/experiment002.rs
@@ -17,6 +17,7 @@ const OF_CMD_CHANNEL:Channel = Channel(String::new());
 use std::sync::Arc;
 
 use chrono::{TimeZone,Local};
+use twitch_irc::message::ReplyToMessage;
 
 
 use crate::core::bot_actions::ExecBodyParams;
@@ -180,7 +181,8 @@ async fn sayout(params : ExecBodyParams) {
             .botmgrs
             .chat
             .say_in_reply_to(
-                &params.msg, 
+                Channel(params.clone().msg.channel_login().to_string()),
+                params.clone().msg.message_id().to_string(), 
                 String::from("Invalid arguments"),
                 params.clone()
             ).await;